Restaurants and Other Food Sources

Breakfast and Lunch

The Islander
63 North Ferry Road
Open daily 6 am to 3 pm, except Wednesday Handicapped accessible. Dinner, Thursday through Saturday. Monday's Hamberger Night.

Breakfast and Lunch. 44A North Ferry Road (next to Roy Reeve Insurance). Open 8:30 am to 5:30 pm. Mexican specialties.

17 Grand Avenue
The Coffee Cellar opens at 5:15 am. The Market Cafe, a deli with seating indoors and out, is open for lunch and takeout.

S.I. Heights Pharmacy
19 Grand Avenue in the Heights
Breakfact and lunch, daily 8:30 am to 2:30 pm. Counter. Newspapers

Lunch and Dinner

Bob's Fish Market
87 North Ferry Road
Year-round fish market. Fish, lobsters, clams daily. Dinner, nearly year-round.

Cafe 27
27 North Ferry Road
Dinner nearly year round.

Chequit Inn
23 Grand Avenue
Open daily for lunch and dinner, year-round.

18 Bay
23 N. Ferry Rd. -
Rt 114 & Duvall Street .
Dinner.  Indoor & outdoor dining. Catering off & on premises. Hours/Reservations:

The Vue, The Restaurant at the Shelter Island Country Club
26 Sunnyside Avenue

The Dory Restaurant
Bridge Street
Lunch and dinner, warm months. Indoor and deck dining. Bar year-round.




Sunset Beach Restaurant & Hotel
35 Shore Road
Memorial Day to Labor Day. Deck dining overlooking Shelter Island Bay.

Sweet Tomato's Restaurant & Bar

15 Grand Avenue
Open year round for dining, catering, and parties. Serving Italian and continental cuisine with indoor and outdoor dining. Closed Wednesdays.

Pridwin Hotel
Crescent Beach
Diningroom overlooking the bay; open during warm months.

Bella Vita Pizza & Restaurant
53 North Ferry Road
Pizza, pasta, and heroes
Open year-round.


The Tavern at Shelter Island House
11 Stearns Point Road
631-749-5659 OPEN year-round. Dedication to local farmers and fishermen ensure the dishes celebrate freshness and inspiration. New American style menu with Mediterranean flair are complemented by handcrafted cocktails to round out your exceptional dining experience. Seasonally driven menus, ambiance and hours change from al fresco to fireside dinning.

Clark's Fish House

South Fery Road (opposite Congdon Rd.)
Fresh fish daily. Year-round; Opening June 2012

Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe
Corner of Smith Street and Midway Road
Year-round fish market and dinners to go; outdoor summer dinner dining.

63 South Menantic Road
Island Boatyard
Continental dining. Lunch and dinner. Nearly year-round.

Rams's Head Inn

108 Ram Island Drive
Shelter Island's "Inn for all Seasons" overlooking Coecle's Harbor.
Chef: Joe Smith

Vine Street  Cafe
41 South Ferry Road
Year-round, Thursday through Monday



Deli's, Food Markets and Catering

Shelter Island IGA Market 
Complete Deli, Gourmet Foods, Grocery, In-Store Bakery, Meats, Produce, Dairy, Frozen Foods. HOMETOWN PROUD IGA.

Reddings Gourmet Market
Bridge Street. Heights. Large selection of groaceries, sandwiches, fresh baked goods, fresh produce, beer, ice, and newspapers. Open late. Phone orders welcome. Across from Piccozzi's Mobil at Dering Harbor Marina. (631)749-6080

Tussie's Mini Mart & Gas Station
35 South Ferry Road, OPEN LATE for your conveinece - located on the way to South Ferry - Stop in for Hot Coffee, fresh pastries, bagels, groceries, cigarettes, ICE COLD beer & soda, milk, bread, sandwiches, snacks galore. Beach and fishing items too!! Adding new items all the time!! (631) 749-3500. 

Eagle Deli
25 West Neck Road. Open daily. An old fashioned Spanish style delicatessen. Homemade salads, hot and cold sandwiches, Boars Head cold cuts, cold beer, soda, ice, cigarettes, dairy, bread, groceries, coffee, tea to go. 

43 North Ferry Road.
In the Center. Deli and  market. Butcher.

Shelter Island Wine Bar - Local Wine Tastings Weekly.

Whale's Tale
Ice Cream, Canolli, Internet Cafe, Minature Golf.

Tuck's Shop
75 North Menantic Road
Ice Cream





Home is maintained by Shillingburg & Associates